Ubuntu 9.04 Jaunty Jackalope feels rushed and premature
They could have called it the Rushed Ram or Bugsy Bear, but instead its a fictional creature Jackalope. Ubuntu’s latest tries to bring some innovation to the table, after the intermediate Ibex, but unfortunately it doesn’t feel ready from day one. Ever since Mark Shuttleworth said that Ubuntu should be visually as cool as Mac OSX, I have been waiting for the Ubuntu release to deliver this – after all there are lots of smaller distros out there focusing on strong visual appeal. It seems that we are still in the wait mode for this to happen, even after Jaunty’s release. Read on…
The most obvious improvements in this release are the notification system (see Shuttleworth’s blog) and improved boot speed. The notifications bring new uniform notifications of various system events for the end user, such as network connections/disconnects, volume changes from hot keys and so on. I see this as an improvement in terms of usability and visual appeal. The notes itself are somewhat dark in colors, perhaps to match some of the new themes better – on the other hand they don’t quite match with the classic Human theme which still is the default. The boot process on the other hand has really become faster – I did not clock the difference, but it is very noticeable. Also I have to give credit for the new Gnome login screen which actually looks good (and also has rather dark toned colors).
Speaking of visual appearance, Since Shuttleworth’s vision to improve the looks of Ubuntu, they have been releasing some darker themes. The Ibex introduced theme ‘Dark room’, and the Jaunty comes with ‘New wave’ and ‘Dust’ themes. Event though I have always hated the bizarre brown/orange theme of Ubuntu, I have to say that these new additions don’t really improve things. I don’t know what is it, but somehow they don’t feel complete or polished enough – the final touch is missing. And I also don’t understand that whats the obsession with rather dark color schemes? The new wallpaper, even though it should matter as it is easily changed, deserves a special recognition: It is the lamest Ubuntu wallpaper in a while. I quite liked the more artistic approach of Ibex’s or Hardy’s wallpaper, but this new one goes back to the Ubuntu tradition of delivering some kind of lame, meaningless, brown stripes on screen. Why is it so difficult for Ubuntu to make a polished looking release? The first impression is everything in attracting new Linux users.
However thing that most concerns me about this new release is that it seems to be contain some rather big showstopper grade bugs. My Thinkpad T41 using Jaunty acts very slow and the screen redraws seem to bring CPU load to 100%, making the whole system rather painful to use. Overall your mileage depends on your hardware, but I always find it surprising when some distro doesn’t correctly on this oldish laptop – that is because generally the Thinkpad’s are possibly the best supported laptops for Linux, and on the other hand this laptop has flawlessy worked on a HUGE number of distributions (for exp. all Ubuntu’s starting from Feisty), so it is always interesting when someone still manages to break the compatibility with this hardware. The CPU usage bug is reported by many, there seem to be a lot of problems with WLAN/WPA2 and more…you can track the bug squashing work by having a look at Launchpad.
Overall it is a typical Ubuntu release. Brings something new, but nothing ground breaking and is very similar to the previous relese. In this release the changes are perhaps more apparent than in the previous two (Hardy, Ibex). The maturity to my eyes doesn’t seem as good as it was with the Ibex on day 1, so I would give it a few weeks to improve until installing or upgrading. I really don’t see why they stick with the 6 month release cycle as it obviously is too short to introduce anything significantly new, or to stabilize software. I find it somewhat paradoxical that actually the previous release Intrepid Ibex is now in it’s prime. But give Jaunty a month or two, and the huge user base of Ubuntu will guarantee that the most common bugs are found and fixed, and Jaunty evolves into a nice stable release – just before Karmic Koala hits the servers…
If you can’t wait, you can grap it from Ubuntu.com













May 4th, 2009 at 11:43 am
A Fedora fanboy? No way man! I strongly dislike distros which prefer purest FOSS software with the cost of compatibility,usability and practicality. Fedora is nothing but a RedHat beta sandbox.
The best thing about Ubuntu is that “everybody” is using it. This results in bugreports, workarounds and documentation for just about any problem.
Regarding the high CPU and low performance on old Radeon GPUs I found this: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/xserver-xorg-video-ati/+bug/363238
So the fix is simple for anyone who is not using Linux for the first time. Apply this piece of code to your /etc/X11/xorg.conf -file
Section “Device”
Identifier “Configured Video Device”
Option “RenderAccel” “on”
Option “AccelMethod” “XAA”
Option “AGPMode” “4″
EndSection
May 3rd, 2009 at 5:39 pm
if you have an Intel graphics cards, then i think that your speed drawing issue may come from the fact they are using a recent intel grphics drivers with the 2.6.28 kernel which lead to speed regressions and instability.
That’s why mandriva 2009 spring is shipped with a 2.6.29 kernel.
http://wiki.mandriva.com/en/2009.1_Tour
http://wiki.mandriva.com/en/2009.1_Notes
May 3rd, 2009 at 4:56 pm
Let me guess… ermm…. Fedora fanboy?
May 1st, 2009 at 3:55 pm
I usually don’t respond to these reviews but yours is so subjective as to be almost meaningless. Most of your problem seems to be with the visuals (browns). I could not agree less. From the first moment I found Ubuntu I have been very pleased with the earth-tone colors. It’s different and better than anything else out in the market. The look is in the eye of the beholder and as you can see, opinions vary. The new 9.04 NBR is absolutely awesome and has given me renewed interest in my netbook (XP made in miserable to use).
May 1st, 2009 at 2:59 pm
Are you running the final release? I’ve got 9.04 installed on an ext4 filesystem here on an Inspiron 1545 and it looks and feel slick and polished and very quick, much more so than Ibex which I had installed previously?
Personally I quite like the 6 month slow and steady cycle as (I’m gonna be in for a kicking here) the big bang approach really flew back in the faces of the KDE developers although I do feel that it was undeserved, but then that’s just my personal preference.
May 1st, 2009 at 1:36 pm
Installed Jaunty on my Asus Aspire One and it flies. I definitely feels faster than Ibex. Going to upgrade my main system pretty quick too. I didn’t have to do any tweaking at all to get my Asus working except the normal restricted extras and codecs installed.
Pretty solid for a .04 release. The .10 releases are usually the stable releases, i’m not disappointed at all, in fact i think the steady progress of Ubuntu is exciting and thrilling to watch. I don’t run windows any more and i haven’t missed it.